Best Pacifier for Breastfed Babies 2018 – Buying Guide

Best Pacifier for Breastfed BabyA pacifier can at times be irritant for the baby, especially if it’s not comfortable and safe. Parents searching the best pacifier for breastfed baby should factor in key aspects like the construction, quality and durability before divvying out any bucks. With so much variety and designs available, it is hard to select the best pacifier. Do not worry, we have got you covered. Here are 10 top pacifiers to help you pick the best for your toddler.

Best Pacifier for Breastfed Baby 2018

Below is the table which displays the top 10 best pacifiers for breastfed babies. Each pacifier is selected by our experts after careful deliberation.

NameSilicone TypeGood AspectsWeightPieces
Philips Avent SCF190/01 Soothie 0-3mth Green (Amazon’s Choice)

Hospitable-gradeLatex Free – BPA Free0.64 ounces2
Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier, Blue, 0-3 (Editor’s Choice)

Hospitable-gradeLatex Free – BPA Free1.44 ounces2
Philips AventBPA Free Soothie Pacifier (Amazon’s Choice)

Hospitable-gradeLatex Free – BPA Free0.32 ounces2
Philips AVENT Soothie Pacifier, 0-3 Months, 2 Packs

Hospitable-gradeLatex Free, Phthalate Free, BPA Free, Lead Free0.64 ounces2
WubbaNub Infant Pacifier – Giraffe

Medical gradeLatex Free0.64 ounces1+Giraffe
MAM Glow in the Dark Night Orthodontic

Silicone SkinSoft NippleBPA/BPS-Free0.8 ounces2
WubbaNub Elephant Pacifier (Editor’s Choice)Medical gradeBPA, Phthalate and PVC free1.6 ounces1+Elephant toy
Philips AVENT Freeflow Pacifier BPA, Free Blue

Silicon nipple (2-Qty)BPA, Phthalate, Latex and Lead Free1.6 ounces2
WubbaNub Brown Monkey Pacifier

Medical-grade siliconeBPA free, toxin free, dishwasher safe1.92 ounces1+Monkey toy
WubbaNub Brown Puppy Pacifier (Amazon’s Choice)

medical-grade siliconePhthalate, lead and toxin free6.1 ounces1+Puppy toy

Philips Avent SCF190/01 Soothie 0-3mth Green – Amazon’s Current Bestseller

Philips Avent SCF190/01 Soothie Review
This Philips Avent pacifier is a brilliant accessory that is highly reliable and durable with an Amazon rating of over 4 and an affordable price. The product has been built to promote healthy and safe suckling with soft and comfortable ‘biting’ that will make your toddler joyous. The latex-free pacifier is specially designed using silicone and is apt for kids aged 3 months or older. The material used for designing the tool helps shape the jaw and gums of your toddler promoting healthy growth.

 No doubt it is the best pacifier for breastfed baby and almost all parents like it. The only thing some parents demand is the pacifier clip which they have to buy separately. The product should have a pacifier included, especially keeping in mind it is for 0 to 3 months old baby.    

Pros
  • An inexpensive product great for a baby’s healthy suckling
  • The silicone product helps develop jaw and gums shaping them nicely
Cons
  • Would have been better with a pacifier clip

Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier, Blue, 0-3 – Natural and Inexpensive Option

Philips Avent Soothie Pacifier Review
With an Amazon rating of over 4.5 out of 5, we highly recommend this latex-free blue Soothie Pacifier by Philips Avent. The best pacifier for breastfed baby has been crafted using special design techniques to calm the toddler’s Orthodontic. The BPA free product supports the natural development of your baby’s teeth and gums while the colorful design makes it a nice bedtime buddy. The one-piece construction has elements of reliability and durability built into it along with hospital grade silicon for added safety.

It’s a must-have for your baby as it comes at an affordable price of less than $4, however, the design could have been better. The blockage of CO2 completely escaping the pacifier before inhaling is something some parents think about. 

Pros
  • The pacifier brand is used in clinics by medical professionals to calm infant’s orthodontics
  • Helps in the natural development of baby’s teeth and gums
  • Dishwasher safe and can be sterilized
  • Available in different packaging
Cons
  • Hospital design supersedes Philip type

Philips AventBPA Free Soothie Pacifier – Safe & Reliable Option

Philips AventBPA Free Soothie Pacifier Review
This awesome best pacifier for breastfed baby is a great durable silicon product that ensures healthy suckling. A definite buy-worthy accessory for your toddler that is a bestseller on Amazon with a rating of over 4! Since it’s made of pure silicon, the material doesn’t get sticky nor develops any odor or flavor that might make your toddler fussy.

 New parents should zero in on this inexpensive yet safe and reliable pacifier that is also used in clinics thanks to its high safety attributes. The soother comes in a package of two with a simple design that is dishwasher safe. 

It has a little low rating compared to other two I discussed above, but that does not mean it is lower in quality than those.

Pros
  • Some parents complain their babies do not like them
  • Others have issues with the material
Cons
  • A great pacifier made of soft silicone that promotes healthy suckling
  • Used in clinics by healthcare professionals for its safety features

Philips AVENT Soothie Pacifier, 0-3 Months, 2 Packs – Amazon’s Durable and Affordable Product

Philips AVENT Soothie Pacifier Review
With an Amazon ranking of over 4, we highly recommend this Soothie Pacifier by the most trusted brand in the world, Philips Avent. A slap-up for newborns and infants, this pacifier is highly durable, made of hospital-grade silicone that ensures proper growth and burgeoning of a toddler’s gums and teeth. Stacked as the best pacifier for breastfed baby on the bestsellers list, the BPA free soother is an instant hit with baby’s who can’t wait to suckle on it.

 Due to its high safety features and reliability, the product is widely distributed in healthcare institutes across the U.S.  For this reason, I strongly suggest this for your baby considering it is super affordable.

Pros
  • The pacifier is used in hospitals nationwide
  • The soother is used by medical professionals to calm newborns
  • BPA free and highly durable
  • Sized and shaped for baby’s mouth
  • Made with hospital-grade silicone
  • Reliable, one-piece construction
Cons
  • Some parents complain they are heavy for their baby
  • Others say they fall out easily

WubbaNub Infant Pacifier – Giraffe – Amazon’s Expensive yet Creative Bestseller

WubbaNub Infant Pacifier Review
The WubbaNub Infant Pacifier – Giraffe scores big in the design department. Not that it has any less functionality in comparison to others ranked high as best pacifier for breastfed baby. The latex-free product has an Amazon rating of over 4 and costs higher than Avent’s products with a colorful Giraffe design that your baby will love. It’s made with a Soothie (TM) medical grade silicone so that there is no dirt or grime buildup in cracks nor any sticky goo that may irritate your baby or cause discomfort.

 Highly recommended for newborns, the Wubbanub pacifier comes packed in a clear polybag with header card but is a little expensive for parents on a stringent budget. If your kid loves stuffed toys, they might love Giraffe.  

Pros
  • It’s distributed in clinics, well-baby units and NICU nationwide
  • Crafted using a Soothie(TM) medical grade silicon
  • The latex-free pacifier is a durable one-piece construction ensuring no germs inside cracks so the pacifier stays clean
  • Apt for newborns less than 6 months of age or toddlers without teeth
Cons
  • A little expensive compared to other simple options like Philips AVENT Soothie Pacifier, 0-3 Months, 2.
  • It is lightweight and falls out of the baby’s mouth easily

MAM Glow in the Dark Night Orthodontic – Affordable & Creative Baby’s dummy

MAM Glow in the Dark Night Orthodontic Review
The MAM Glow in the Dark Night Orthodontic soother is designed for a sensitive skin to provide comfort to the baby while suckling. The design includes an open shield that provides extra air flow while the symmetrical orthodontic nipple supports the toddler’s jaw and teeth development. The comforter by MAM is a glow in the dark accessory and has an Amazon rating of over 4.5. It includes a textured surface and various tiny openings on the soother shield to enable air to circulate properly.

 Strongly recommended for new parents searching for the best pacifier for breastfed baby, this one is affordable, has a great design but does not come equipped with a pacifier case.  Give it a try, your baby would love it. 

Pros
  • It’s designed for sensitive skin with an open shield that provides extra air flow
  • The symmetrical orthodontic nipple is great for baby’s jaw and teeth development
  • The pacifier contains a silicone Skin Soft nipple with a silky texture loved by baby’s
Cons
  • The product package does not include a pacifier case
  • Water gets trapped in the nipple

WubbaNub Elephant Pacifier – Amazon’s Expensive But Durable Bestseller

WubbaNub Elephant Pacifier Review
The WubbaNub Elephant Pacifier is a creative baby’s dummy with an Amazon rating of over 4. The comforter is a pleasant combination of original Pacifier/Plush Animal that is high on functionality and aesthetics. The babies develop an instant liking for the soother thanks to its colorful and zippy design. The pacifier is created with Soothie medical-grade silicone making it easy for your baby to hold it. It’s a top rated, best pacifier for breastfed baby that is BPA, Phthalate and PVC free.

 With a very high rating and practically no faults, I highly recommend it. I have checked reviews and I couldn’t find any good reason not to buy this one for your baby.  

Pros
  • The Original Pacifier/Plush Animal combination soothie is Latex free, BPA, Phthalate and PVC free.
  • Durable one piece construction is both functional and stylish. The patented design makes it easy for baby to grasp.
  • It’s distributed in hospitals, well-baby units & NICU
  • It’s crafted using Soothie medical-grade silicone pacifier
  • Recommended for babies up to six months
Cons
  • It’s a bit costly compared to others

Philips AVENT Freeflow Pacifier BPA, Free Blue – Amazon’s Natural & Safe Soother

Philips AVENT Freeflow Pacifier BPA Review
With an Amazon rating of over 4.5, Philips AVENT Freeflow Pacifier BPA, Free Blue is the best pacifier for breastfed baby, costing less than $6. The Phthalate, Latex, Lead and BPA Free product comes equipped with a simple yet effective design that keeps the pacifier purged including six holes in the shield that allow extra air flow. The soother is available in a range of colors, shapes and patterns, and is ideal for sensitive skin. The pacifier comes equipped with an elastic string attached to the other end of the comforter to loop through the PUL cloth fabric.

Pros
  • It is BPA, Phthalate, Latex and Lead Free
  • Orthodontic pacifier designed for natural oral development
  • The pacifier promotes natural development of baby’s teeth and gums
  • Six holes in shield allow extra air flow, ideal for sensitive skin
  • It is dishwasher safe and can be sterilized
  • Includes a snap on hygienic cap to keep the nipple clean
  • Has a white plastic clip that baby can’t pull off
Cons
  • There is literally no negative feedback on it, so it’s the best pacifier out there

WubbaNub Brown Monkey Pacifier – A Creative but Costly Soother

WubbaNub Brown Monkey Pacifier Review
The soft silicone based WubbaNub Brown Monkey Pacifier ranks high on Amazon as the best pacifier for breastfed baby. The product is made of silicone that is soft and chewy to ensure safe and happy suckling. The effective design that is BPA and toxin free protects your toddler from any discomfort or soreness as it grows teeth. It’s a dishwasher and freezer safe product that includes a zippy unique animal/plush combination design for the pacifier with bright and vivid colors that will be loved by the baby.

 A reliable and creative pacifier with a very good rating. I highly recommend this for all the parents.  

Pros
  • Made of chewable and soft silicone
  • Unique animal/plush design with bright colors and monkey shape that your baby will love
  • BPA free, toxin free and dishwasher safe
  • Ensures safe and happy suckling
Cons
  • A very few complained it’s hard to wash

WubbaNub Brown Puppy Pacifier  – Amazon’s Innovative yet Costly Bestseller

WubbaNub Brown Puppy Pacifier Review
With an Amazon rating of over 4, the WubbaNub Brown Puppy Pacifier is a highly recommended soother that comes equipped with a cool animal design that your baby will adore. It entails a modern design with a puppy frame that looks stylish with its snazzy pattern. The BPA free product is a durable one piece construction that stays close to your baby. The lead and toxic free product is safe and easy to use with complete adherence to established regulations for small parts and sharp edge aspects for baby pacifiers.

A creative patented design yet a bit expensive!

Pros
  • Stylish design with a trendy puppy frame design
  • Phthalate, lead and toxin free pacifier
  • Includes a Patented design that makes it easy for baby to grasp
  • Made with Soothie medical-grade silicone
  • BPA & Silicone Free
Cons
  • A bit expensive compared to other simple & affordable products
  • Does not come equipped with accessories like a pacifier case or clip

All the products we mentioned above are equally safe and high-quality, so choose any that fits your bill and liking. The creative and affordable options like Baby Teething Toys, Soft Silicone Natural BPA, MAM Glow in the Dark Night Orthodontic, Philips Avent SCF190/01 Soothie 0-3mth Green, and WubbaNub Infant Pacifier – Giraffe are all healthy and adorable for babies.